English
Bombay HC rejects Agniveer's plea in assault case, upholds self-perceived gender identity under Indian law. (img: X)
Mumbai: The Bombay High Court has ruled that transgender persons who identify as women are entitled to seek protection under the sexual harassment provisions of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS), holding that their self-perceived gender identity cannot be questioned merely because they are transgender.
Dismissing a criminal revision application filed by a 24-year-old Army Agniveer, Vishal Sunil Ingle, Justice Mehroz K Pathan of the Nagpur Bench recently upheld an Akot sessions court order rejecting his application for discharge from the criminal proceedings.
The Court held that allegations of assault and outraging the modesty of a woman can sustain prosecution even when the complainant is a transgender person who identifies as a woman. It observed that the question of whether the relationship was consensual would have to be examined during the course of trial.
The matter originated from an FIR registered at a police station in Akola district on November 1, 2025, following a complaint by a transgender woman alleging sexual assault and harassment by Ingle, who was serving as an Agniveer in the Indian Army.
According to the prosecution, the complainant had been undergoing hormonal treatment since 2015 and began wearing women's clothing in 2021 as part of her gender transition. She alleged that Ingle entered into a relationship with her on the assurance of marriage and sexually assaulted her on October 28, 2025. She further alleged that two days later, he took her to a flat on his motorcycle after asking her to meet him at a bus stand, where another incident of sexual assault allegedly took place.
The police invoked Sections 75 (sexual harassment), 296 (obscene acts) and 351(2) (criminal intimidation) of the BNS, along with Section 18(D) of the Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Act, 2019.
Seeking discharge, Ingle contended that Section 75 of the BNS could not be invoked in the case since the provision was intended to protect women and the statutory definition of a woman referred to a female human being.
His counsel also argued that the complainant had obtained a transgender identity certificate only in February 2026, several months after the alleged incidents, and therefore could not claim the benefit of the provision for the relevant period.
The defence further maintained that the relationship was consensual and that the BNS did not contain a provision corresponding to the erstwhile Section 377 of the Indian Penal Code. Opposing the application, Additional Public Prosecutor Swati V Kolhe submitted that transgender persons identifying as women were entitled to legal protection and that their self-determined gender identity could not be disputed.
Rejecting the defence submissions, the High Court relied on the Supreme Court's landmark 2014 judgment in National Legal Services Authority v. Union of India, which recognised the right of transgender persons to determine and identify their own gender.
Justice Pathan referred to the provisions of the Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Act, 2019, particularly its definition of a transgender person, which includes transgender men and women irrespective of whether they have undergone sex reassignment surgery, hormonal treatment or other medical interventions.
The Court observed that the absence of a formal identity certificate at the time of the alleged offence could not, by itself, prevent a transgender person from asserting their gender identity or invoking the relevant legal protections.
It also noted that Section 4 of the 2019 Act, as it stood when the alleged incidents occurred in October 2025, expressly recognised the right to self-perceived gender identity. The Court clarified that the subsequent amendment to the 2019 legislation in 2026 would not alter the legal position applicable to the alleged incidents, which had taken place in 2025.
The High Court observed that the complainant had consistently identified herself as a woman and that such self-determination could not be questioned at the stage of considering the accused's discharge application. It further found that the allegations in the FIR prima facie attracted Section 75 of the BNS, while the material collected during the investigation provided sufficient grounds for the prosecution to proceed.
Addressing the defence argument that the relationship was consensual, the Court held that the issue required an assessment of evidence during trial and could not be conclusively determined at the discharge stage. "The allegations of assault and outraging the modesty of a woman can be sustained even where the victim is a transgender person who identifies herself as a woman," the Court observed. Finding no ground to interfere with the sessions court's order rejecting discharge, the High Court dismissed the criminal revision application as devoid of merit.
Location : Mumbai
Published : 17 November 2026, 7:58 PM IST
Related News