A comment linking traditional cremation practices to rising pollution has triggered a sharp political confrontation in Uttar Pradesh. While one side calls for eco friendly reforms, the other sees it as an attack on faith, culture, and personal beliefs.
SP leader links traditional cremation practices to rising.
New Delhi: A fresh political controversy unfolded after a senior Samajwadi Party leader raised concerns over the environmental impact of traditional cremation practices. The remark, made during a discussion on sustainability and pollution, quickly escalated into a heated debate, drawing strong reactions from rival parties and reigniting questions about how environmental priorities intersect with cultural traditions.
Samajwadi Party leader RK Chaudhary argued that the burning of bodies using traditional funeral pyres contributes significantly to air and water pollution. He pointed out that large quantities of wood are used for cremations, leading to deforestation, while ash and remains released into rivers worsen water quality. Emphasising environmental responsibility, he suggested that the government should actively promote electric and gas based cremation facilities as cleaner alternatives to reduce carbon emissions and protect natural resources.
The SP leader framed his remarks as a science based appeal rather than a cultural critique. He stressed that deteriorating air quality, particularly in the Indo Gangetic plains, demands difficult but necessary conversations. According to him, incentives for modern cremation methods could balance environmental protection with evolving social practices. However, the sensitive nature of the subject and its timing ensured that the statement did not remain confined to environmental discourse.
No PUC, No Fuel: Delhi targets polluting vehicles amid severe air pollution; Full story here
The Bharatiya Janata Party reacted sharply, accusing the opposition of hurting religious sentiments in the name of environmentalism. Party spokespersons described the comments as insensitive and out of touch with cultural realities. They argued that cremation rites are deeply personal and spiritually meaningful, and questioning them amounts to interference in religious freedom. BJP leaders also alleged that the opposition was selectively targeting traditions instead of addressing larger contributors to pollution such as industrial emissions and vehicular smoke.
According to the ruling party, focusing on funeral rites diverts attention from policy level failures in pollution control. BJP representatives challenged the opposition to present concrete solutions for industrial waste and urban congestion rather than politicising matters associated with death and faith. They warned that any attempt to stigmatise religious practices would provoke strong public resistance.
Environmental experts have long highlighted the ecological footprint of traditional cremations. A single funeral pyre can consume several hundred kilograms of wood, adding to deforestation and carbon emissions. Ash disposal into rivers further affects aquatic ecosystems. Over the years, initiatives promoting green cremation methods and electric furnaces have been introduced in several cities, though adoption has remained limited due to social beliefs linked to last rites.
The practice of Antyesti holds profound emotional and religious significance for many families, making rapid change difficult. Despite awareness campaigns and improved infrastructure, many continue to prefer traditional methods. The political debate has now brought this long standing issue into public focus, transforming an environmental challenge into a broader cultural and ideological confrontation.
By raising the issue, the Samajwadi Party has opened a new front in Uttar Pradesh political discourse, where environmental issues increasingly overlap with identity and tradition. With local body elections approaching, debates around pollution, faith, and governance are expected to intensify, placing voters at the crossroads of modern sustainability goals and age old customs.
