English
The first public consultation on Maharashtra's proposed Uniform Civil Code witnesses diverse opinions at Konkan Bhavan. (Img: AI)
Mumbai: The first public consultation on Maharashtra’s proposed Uniform Civil Code (UCC) witnessed a wide spectrum of opinions on Saturday, with Muslim organisations questioning the need for a common civil law, women’s rights groups pressing for gender-sensitive reforms and transgender representatives seeking legal recognition for diverse family structures.
The hearing, conducted at Konkan Bhavan in Navi Mumbai, was organised by the committee chaired by retired Supreme Court judge Justice Ranjana Prakash Desai. The panel is undertaking district-wise consultations to gather public feedback on the proposed framework governing marriage, divorce, live-in relationships, maintenance, guardianship and inheritance.
Five of the seven members appointed to the committee, including Justice Desai and Ramesh Patange, participated in the first day of deliberations. The consultation for the Konkan division is scheduled to continue on Sunday.
Representatives of Jamaat-e-Islami Hind and the All India Muslim Personal Law Board (AIMPLB) raised objections to the proposed legislation, contending that a uniform legal framework must not undermine religious freedom or India's pluralistic social fabric.
Mohammed Khalid of Jamaat-e-Islami Hind cautioned that imposing a common framework on communities with distinct religious and cultural practices could aggravate social divisions.
AIMPLB representative Mufti Jasimuddin Qasmi maintained that communities should retain the freedom to follow their respective personal laws in family-related matters. Another representative, Dr Azimuddin, questioned the necessity of introducing a UCC, arguing that its justification must be established through constitutional scrutiny, evidence and substantive public consultation.
Congress MLA Amin Patel, who participated through videoconferencing, also opposed the proposed exercise. He questioned the consultation methodology, particularly the use of a questionnaire containing yes-or-no questions when the actual legislative framework had not been placed in the public domain.
However, some participants from the Muslim community supported reforms within existing personal laws while cautioning against any perception that the proposed legislation was directed at a particular religious group.
Sabah Khan of the Savitri Fatima Foundation for Inclusive Development argued that the objective should be to address discriminatory practices rather than create an impression of punitive legislation targeting Muslim men. She also advocated removing provisions such as restitution of conjugal rights.
The hearing also brought into focus the concerns of LGBTQI groups, which called for a broader understanding of family relationships and legal recognition of partnerships beyond conventional marriage.
Chayanika Shah, representing the queer feminist collective Hasratein-e-Zindagi-Mamooli, advocated legal recognition of civil partnerships between consenting adults and the concept of chosen families.
She highlighted the difficulties faced by transgender persons who may be separated from their natal families and depend on chosen families for emotional, social and financial support. The absence of legal recognition, she pointed out, can create significant obstacles, including while accessing medical treatment.
Women's rights organisations also called for comprehensive reforms covering marriage, adoption, inheritance and civil partnerships. Sandhya Gokhale of the Nari Atyachar Virodhi Manch, an organisation working on gender justice since 1980, cautioned against excessive state interference in consensual relationships, including live-in arrangements.
She stressed that legal reforms should protect individual autonomy and should not result in intrusive monitoring of people's private lives. The organisation also sought changes in adoption-related provisions and a social security framework for vulnerable and marginalised sections.
Representatives of Nomadic and Denotified Tribes (NT-DNT) communities urged the committee to examine the implications of the proposed code on their distinctive social structures and traditional marriage practices.
They pointed out that communities such as Pardhi, Banjara, Gosavi, Gondhali, Garudi, Vadar and Devipujak follow customs that may not necessarily correspond with conventional family-law structures.
Seeking a separate assessment of their traditions, the representatives called for legal recognition of customary marriages and safeguards concerning women's rights to divorce, maintenance and inheritance. They also demanded dedicated consultations with community organisations and researchers, besides constitutional protection for groups covered by special safeguards.
While several organisations expressed apprehensions about the proposed legislation, other participants extended unequivocal support to the idea of a common civil law. Advocate Sanjay Jain endorsed the UCC, contending that a uniform framework was necessary to establish equality in personal and family matters. Advocate Karthikeyan also supported the proposal but emphasised that reforms must be introduced without eroding established customary practices.
The first consultation thus reflected the competing constitutional, social and cultural considerations surrounding the proposed UCC, with participants raising questions ranging from religious freedom and gender equality to individual autonomy and the protection of customary traditions. The committee is expected to consider the submissions received during its district-level consultations while examining the contours of the proposed legislation.
Location : Mumbai
Published : 21 November 2026, 5:08 PM IST
Related News