X (Twitter) to appeal against a Karnataka High Court order enforcing compliance with takedown notices

Karnataka High Court dismissed X’s plea against takedown orders, stating that foreign platforms must follow Indian laws. X raised concerns over free speech and plans to appeal. The case highlights regulation vs. digital freedom debate.

New Delhi: Social media platform X (formerly Twitter) challenged the Indian government's orders to remove certain posts and accounts. However, the Karnataka High Court dismissed X's petition, stating that X must comply with Indian laws.

X's response: Free speech in danger

Expressing concern over the court's decision, X said, "This decision is very worrying, as it will allow millions of police officers to arbitrarily order the removal of posts. We will appeal this decision to protect freedom of expression."

EPFO Set to Launch ATM Withdrawals for PF Accounts by 2026

What did the court say?

Control over social media is essential. The court stated that in today's times, it is extremely important to regulate social media. No social media company can operate in India without oversight.

Indian laws first

The court clearly stated that any company wishing to operate in India must comply with local Indian laws. Even Article 19 is for Indian citizens only. The court clarified that the freedom of expression guaranteed under Article 19 of the Indian Constitution applies only to Indian citizens, not to foreign companies.

 

And American laws will not apply in India. The court also told X that while it operates under American laws, it will have to comply with Indian laws in India. The US judicial system cannot be imposed on India's judicial system.

Questioning the role of algorithms

The court stated that social media algorithms constantly determine what information reaches people. Therefore, these platforms cannot be left completely free.

Vijay Rally Stampede: Actor moves to HC, alleges political conspiracy; Know full story

New laws and digital transformation

The court stated that the digital world is rapidly changing, and the interpretation of laws must also change accordingly. The IT Rules 2021 must also be understood in keeping with the times.

The court concluded, "No social media platform is above the laws of India. India's digital marketplace is not a playground for anyone." X will now appeal this decision, but this case has become an important precedent regarding social media freedom versus government control.

This is a developing story, stay tuned to Dynamite News for further updates.